Access All Areas at the FourFourTwo-sponsored League One club
Fan Nick Judd wonders whether calls for a change at the top are knee-jerk reactions to the season's slow start...
I’m 29 and I’ve already seen Swindon promoted and relegated four times – plus a demotion – as well as 16 managers and two administrations. Not surprisingly, Town finished fifth in a recent study attempting to find the most stressful club to support in the UK. Littlewoods Pools used such scientific tools as promotions/relegations, managerial sackings and off-field dramas in finding Notts County top of the pile.
If County fans are anything like us they’re a suspicious bunch worn down by years of drama on and off the field. Such perennial palava has made some Town fans so used to doom and gloom that they’re instantly resentful when anything goes wrong. For example, only winning two of seven games this season has seen a growing number call for Maurice Malpas’ head.
Malpas: Feeling the heat just seven games in
Malpas’ appointment in January – Chairman Andrew Fitton’s first major decision – wasn’t greeted with champagne and bunting. Townies wanted a big name or former favourite, but ended up with a dour Scot with a poor managerial record north of the border. Yet we respected Fitton’s decision. If anyone deserved the right to pick the manager it’s the man who saved us from the brink of closure. Malpas, he urged, impressed over the other candidates and could bring us Championship football within three years. Who were we to argue?
We’re now eight months in and the club has improved exponentially off the field. On it, Swindon remain consistently inconsistent. Our 3-1 home defeat against 10-man Leeds last week infuriated as many as the opening-day win against Tranmere enthralled. Much like our old boss Andy King, Malpas has polarised opinion, but Colchester United’s sacking of Geraint Williams has fuelled the fires of discontent: three weeks ago the U's thumped us at home.
Malpas could just be a victim of circumstance. After years of upheaval, Town fans are a hard bunch to please: those pleading time in favour of the Scot forget that, for many, patience has slowly been eroded.
My feeling is there is no need for change just yet. When Steve McMahon left we had no option: he was a man so despised that Town fans left in droves. Some never came back. Some of those who stayed saw King as the final straw. Though he sweated blood and tears at a difficult time in the club’s history, his old-school ways and regular radio rants infuriated many.
McMahon: So disliked, some fans still stay away
Me? Well, I guess I’m on a longer fuse than others. Malpas has identified our problems, namely defensive lapses and a threadbare squad; my opinion will be formed by what he does about them. What’s clear is that those venting their spleens at games aren’t helping. It doesn't help, just like it didn’t help King – during whose reign fans continually called for the return of Lou Macari. Macari, like Malpas, won just two of his first seven games. And look at what he achieved…
The best way to judge a manager in my view is to compare what you would do in his position, in each circumstance. On team selection, with what he has available I have agreed with him nearly every time,unlike with some previous managers.
His comments, general honesty, courtesy and accuracy have apparently been good.
Players fitness and training seem OK in principle.
On the negative side,something is wrong with the defensive organisation obviously, with too many basic mistakes. How Malpas deals with this, and the lack of money to buy and pay new players because of understandable prudence by the Board, will determine our season. There is a doubt about his ability to change tactics during games and enthusiasm to gee them up, but it is not really known what goes on behind the scenes.
On the whole, IMO a sound honest man who is feeling his way but it will take time to get consistency, which we have not had for many seasons. I would like to know what the players think of him...... No idea
if we can improve our defence we will be fine though. looking at our defenders casal smith ifil kanyuka morrisson ajofree. we have some talent however ajofree is not as good as he used to be and when vincent is back to form i relish to watch ifil vincent kanyuka and casal
LATEST FOOTBALL NEWS
Bayern sell out Allianz for cup final screening
Ferguson seeking anything but quiet life
Riquelme stunner sends Corinthians crashing
Ivanovic wins Europa League for Chelsea
FIFA: Sao Paulo stadium will be ready on time
He's here, he's there, he's...
The cost of Premier League away travel
FourFourTwo is brought to you by Haymarket Consumer Media & FourFourTwo is part of Haymarket Sport
| International Licensing | © Haymarket Media Group 2010