FREE FourFourTwo newsletters for all!

Register now and get:
  • The inside track on the big issues
  • Tactical insight from our experts
  • Players to watch
  • Analysis & humour
  • Exclusive competitions
  • Stick-men drawings
  • WAGs, bets, bargains & more
See a sample newsletter
Sign up now to avoid disappointment
And why not check out the magazine?

The Real American Football

From the MLS to the national teams to Americans abroad


Jason Davis

See all posts

No, Henry doesn't mean it's NASL 2.0


Friday 30 July 2010 17:33

Thierry Henry, Nery Castillo, Blaise N'Kufo, Alvaro Fernandez and soon Rafa Marquez – all Designated Players signed up by MLS clubs during this new age of big spending and big splashes. 

Some will make major differences for their teams both on the field and in the stands, while hopefully raising the level of play across the league. The summer of 2010 is quickly becoming the most notable period in league history, at least in terms of player acquisition.

At a quick glance, it might look like MLS is headed down the NASL path with gusto. The DP rule promotes big signings and increased payrolls, an odd thing for a league that operates on the margins of American sports without considerable revenues. Just as it did in the 1980s, an arms race could conceivably bankrupt American soccer.

Except things are much different this time around. The rules explicitly prevent any team from turning themselves into a Cosmos-style superclub; three high-profile players don't necessarily make for puddles of red ink, especially if the club plays in a proper stadium with stable ownership in place. The Red Bulls, for all their summer spending, are hardly stressing their corporate owners' pocketbooks. 

Love or hate the way MLS operates, the structure provides a safety net that did not exist in the Go Go 70s. Single-entity is a dirty phrase from a sweetness-and-light-let's-be-like-Europe perspective, but it gives the league's owners and fans the confidence to move forward without fear that everything will go belly-up in short order. MLS hasn't crested the proverbial hill quite yet, but it's getting there. Sharing the burden helps. 

But it's not just the financial factors that will keep MLS from turning into NASL 2.0. A commitment to developing young talent, something the NASL never bothered itself with, balances out the big names and big money. Academy programs are beginning to bear talented fruit, balancing out the "retirement league" image created by the signings of players like Henry and Beckham.

Ask any MLS fan who knows and they'll tell you that the league is finally beginning to show a commitment to producing players rather than simply acquiring them. As with anything the league does, progress is excruciating; but movement is movement, no matter how much the league limits the number of academy graduates allowed per year. 

While names like Thierry Henry and Rafa Marquez will make the biggest splashes and garner the most mainstream attention, names like Andy Najar, Tristen Bowen and Francisco Navas Cobo are equally as important to the future of Major League Soccer. Perhaps more so. Churning out young players could eventually turn into a financial windfall, bringing transfer fees into the league's coffers and bolstering the ability of teams to sign quality players younger than the thirtysomething stars it currently attracts.

The perception problem that afflicts MLS, both internationally and domestically, won't be corrected overnight. It won't be significantly changed by the signing of one French striker or the acquisition of any one player, no matter their pedigree and reputation. It will be changed slowly, over time, through the continued development of the league into a full participant in the world of football. During a different era and under different rules, the NASL was simply not able to participate or not interested in doing so; Major League Soccer is not the NASL.

It's the balance of big signings to homegrown talent that is crucial to turning MLS into a established and respected league on the world stage. Years and perhaps decades away from competing on level terms with Mexico and Europe for players, the impetus to turn the academy system into a legitimate producer of professional-ready talent is real and pressing.

It took years to get there, but Major League Soccer is finally taking the first real steps down a path NASL never intended to travel; that, without a question, is the best evidence that the former will not suffer the fate of the latter.
Indications are that MLS is on the verge of restarting the reserve league.

Combined with a burgeoning academy system, the league now stands on the dawn of a new age that has little to do with the influx of high-priced superstars.

The Real American Football home
More features from FFT.com

USA: News * MLS stats
FFT.com: Features * News * Interviews * Home
Interact: Twitter * Facebook * Forums

or to add your comments

About Jason Davis

A Yank in all connotations of the word, Jason writes entirely too many words that somehow occasionally make sense at his blog Match Fit USA, where he covers the American game in earnest. Never one to overwork his fingers, he also babbles about various topics on the aptly-named American Soccer Show, a weekly podcast.

Spending more time thinking about football (and not the American kind) than most believe healthy, he unfortunately has yet to found a way to support himself doing it. Nevertheless, he soldiers on, waving an over-sized version of Old Glory wherever he goes, hoping for an American World Cup victory before he's too old to realize it happened, and dreaming of the day a washed-up Yank heads to England to finish out his career rather than the other way around.

Comments

  July 31, 2010 15:36

Yorugua said:

The Nery Castillo move is intriguing, if he can replicate the form he had at Olympiacos, the Uruguayan-raised Mexican has a golden opportunity to give MLS it's first superstar. But I'd have to see it to believe it.

BTW what's with MLS banning any team from using the brand name Cosmos? I would rather the NY RedBull played as the Cosmos than as an energy drink collective.

  August 1, 2010 11:03

James Goyder said:

For Thierry Henry this move makes perfect sense because he is obviously no longer at a level where he can continue to excel in the elite European leagues.

I feel David Beckham made the move a little prematurely because, as his loan spells to AC Milan have shown, he could still have got in just about any club side in Europe.

At least the players who head to the MLS to finish ther careers can still play something approaching top clas competitive football. I have more respect for the likes of Henry and Rafael Marquez then I do Fabio Cannavero who will be picking up the final pay packet of is career in the UAE for a team who probably wouldn't even be good enough to play professional football in Italy.

  August 5, 2010 04:45

Ro1980 said:

The MLS should be closed, and all Americans banned from official football.

FourFourTwo.com
Haymarket

FourFourTwo is brought to you by Haymarket Consumer Media & FourFourTwo is part of Haymarket Sport
About Haymarket | International Licensing | © Haymarket Media Group 2010