10 players who really weren't liked by their team-mates
Jon Spurling selects a handful of outcasts who weren't too popular in the dressing room
1. “Well, I know I was brilliant but…”
One of Arsenal’s few reliable performers in the mid-’70s, keeper Jimmy Rimmer spectacularly shot himself in the foot after telling punters in a Southgate pub: “I played well today – it was a shame about the other 10.”
When word filtered back to the dressing room, Jimbo soon departed to Villa. “He wasn’t high on anyone’s Christmas card list,” huffed Gunners defender David O’Leary.
2. McGovern damned by association
Signed to fill the nine-game gap left by Billy Bremner’s suspension in August 1974, John McGovern was vilified by fans and team-mates alike as unpopular coach Brian Clough’s pet in Ol’ Big ’Ead’s fateful 44-day Elland Road spell.
McGovern played just four times, later joining Cloughie at Nottingham Forest to win two European Cups. “Perhaps we were a bit hard on the lad,” admitted Peter Lorimer.
3. Seal of disapproval
Get FourFourTwo Newsletter
The best features, fun and footballing quizzes, straight to your inbox every week.
“After Rodney Marsh arrived,” trilled Manchester City winger Neil Young of the ex-QPR maverick’s March 1972 transfer, “I’d attempt a give-and-go, and there he was juggling the ball like a bloody seal.”
Young’s complaints were echoed by exasperated City players as the wheels come off the Sky Blues’ title challenge. “He was a flashy sod,” blasted skipper Mike Doyle. “They acted like a Northern Mafia,” countered Marsh.
4. Chopper’s sweet revenge
After scything down Liverpool’s Emlyn Hughes in retaliation for Crazy Horse breaking Peter Osgood’s leg in a 1966 League Cup tie, Chelsea hatchet man Ron Harris was hotly pursued by Reds tough guy Tommy Smith.
Expecting to be throttled, Harris was stunned when a smirking Smith told him: “I could get to like you, Chopper.” “It turns out that the Liverpool players weren’t too keen on Emlyn’s whining voice either,” recounted Harris.
5. “Talk us through your forehand, Gordon…”
Irritating his Millwall team-mates throughout the 1973/74 season with his general cockiness and penchant for Norman Wisdom impressions, winger Gordon ‘Merlin’ Hill copped some stick. Whether pretending to be TV reporters keen to speak to him about his tennis skills, or by hiding his stuff in the dressing room, ‘Merlin’ was the butt of many a joke. Until he joined Manchester United in 1975, becoming an Old Trafford cult hero. Nice one, lads.
6. Busby’s skills don’t Bowl over Stan
QPR’s 1970s legend Stan Bowles didn’t rate reserve striker Martyn Busby. “I get it, Stan,” ventured a puzzled Busby at half-time in one game. “You want me to keep making these decoy runs. Is that why you’re not giving me the ball, so we can fool the opposition?” Not quite. “We’re not giving you the ball because you’re crap,” came the sneering reply.
7. “He plays when he wants…’
When strike partner Kevin Campbell and terrace favourite defender Colin Cooper were sold by newly promoted Nottingham Forest in August 1998, Pierre van Hooijdonk asked for a transfer. That request rejected, he went on strike for three months.
The Dutchman’s first post-strike goal came against rivals Derby in November but his team-mates preferred to celebrate with Scot Gemmill, who’d set it up. “I couldn’t give a shit what Pierre does next,” stropped team-mate Steve Stone at the end of the season.
8. “If you want to eat with us, pass to us”
Emotions were running high within Zaire’s 1974 World Cup camp after a 9-0 defeat to Yugoslavia. Matters worsened when the team accused midfielder Kidumu Mantantu of deliberately over-hitting his passes to make them look bad in practice matches. After a hasty internal enquiry, the midfield star – and captain – was forced to eat his meals alone and train by himself. Ouch.
9. Sammer puts his foot in it
In the 1980s, displaying any kind of leadership qualities in East German football was frowned upon. So when Dynamo Dresden youngster Matthias Sammer began bossing and cajoling his fellow pros, the squad exacted its revenge on the renegade midfielder by presenting him with a new set of football boots which were three sizes too large. “It was pure harassment,” squealed Sammer. He quickly headed west when the Berlin Wall fell.
10. The biggest ego in the Big Apple
Ex-Barcelona centre-back Rafa Marquez did little to endear himself to New York Red Bulls colleagues in a two-year stay. “Unfortunately there isn’t an equal level between perhaps Thierry Henry and myself, and our team-mates,” he said in 2011, hammering a nail into his own coffin.
After some long, awkward silences in the dressing room, he was sold to Mexican club Leon in 2013. It’s fair to say that none of his ex-team-mates waved him goodbye.
This feature originally appeared in the February 2014 issue of FourFourTwo. Subscribe!
Jon Spurling is a history and politics teacher in his day job, but has written articles and interviewed footballers for numerous publications at home and abroad over the last 25 years. He is a long-time contributor to FourFourTwo and has authored seven books, including the best-selling Highbury: The Story of Arsenal in N5, and Get It On: How The '70s Rocked Football was published in March 2022.