Carlisle United season preview 2023/24: How Carlisle plan on staying in League One

Carlisle United season preview 2023/24 Carlisle United react during the penalty shootout during the Sky Bet League 2 Play-Off Final between Carlisle United and Stockport County at Wembley Stadium, London on Sunday 28th May 2023. (Photo by Tom West/MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)

The Carlisle United season preview 2023/24 focuses on an inevitably difficult campaign, but an enjoyable one nonetheless.

Simpson worked miracles to inspire Carlisle to promotion: he’s ready for League One, but it’s less clear if the club is, structurally. If Owen Moxon stays, United need their star midfielder at his best every week to have a chance.

Losing top scorer Kristian Dennis doesn't help in their cause to survive, either. It'll be difficult, but Carlisle will fight for every last point in the third tier. 

Carlisle United season preview 2023/24, the fan's view: Lee Rooney (@bruntonbugle)

Last season was beyond even our wildest expectations. All of the experts had us finishing around 18th or 19th [in our defence, we predicted 16th – Ed.] so to turn things around and win the play-off final was unbelievable. 

The big talking point is whether ace midfielder Owen Moxon will stay. He’s going to have a queue of suitors after a brilliant breakthrough season with us. He deserves to play at a higher level, so I don’t think anybody would begrudge him a transfer, but if he is off, it would be good to get the move (and the money!) sorted fairly quickly. 

Our key player will be Jon Mellish. Although Moxon was superb, Big Jon was essential to how we play, as a box-to-box defender in a back three, causing chaos all over the pitch. He’s now our longest-serving player and a huge fans’ favourite.

Jon Mellish of Carlisle United during the Sky Bet League Two between Walsall and Carlisle United at Poundland Bescot Stadium on April 10, 2023 in Walsall, United Kingdom. (Photo by James Williamson - AMA/Getty Images)

Jon Mellish will be key in Carlisle's survival hopes (Image credit: Getty Images)

Our most underrated player is Jack Armer, outstanding as a wing-back on the left side. It’s criminal that he didn’t feature in the League Two Team of the Season. He’s racked up more than 100 league appearances for Carlisle and only turned 22 in April. 

Look out for Taylor Charters, 21. He had a really good spell in the team before Christmas, only for injury to rule him out for four months. He bounced back well in the play-offs and struck the winning penalty at Wembley.

The thing my club really gets right is the matchday fan experience, which I never would have said several years ago. It’s improved hugely – getting to the ground early these days is a must. 

I’m least looking forward to playing Exeter, a long old slog for both clubs.

CARLISLE, ENGLAND - APRIL 29: Carlisle United Manager Paul Simpson reacts on the touchline during the Sky Bet League Two between Carlisle United and Salford City at Brunton Park on April 29, 2023 in Carlisle, England. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

Paul Simpson is adored by the Brunton Park faithful (Image credit: Getty Images)

The fans’ opinion of the gaffer is that he can walk on water. He’s produced a squad, with real togetherness, that can switch with ease between two different formations in a game. Paul Simpson has a job for life here.

If he left, he should be replaced by another person with close links to the club: Peter Murphy at Annan Athletic or Danny Grainger at Workington, both ex-players. The latter helped to coach our youth side last season. 

We’ll finish a solid 12th with a couple of good cup runs thrown in. I think we will exceed expectations once again.

Season previews for the Premier League, League One and League Two are all available HERE

Subscribe to FourFourTwo today! Guarantee the finest football stories and interviews dropping on your doorstep every month

The FourFourTwo Season Preview issue is available in shops now. Click here to order yours with free delivery

Ryan Dabbs
Staff writer

Ryan is a staff writer for FourFourTwo, joining the team full-time in October 2022. He first joined Future in December 2020, working across FourFourTwo, Golf Monthly, Rugby World and Advnture's websites, before eventually earning himself a position with FourFourTwo permanently. After graduating from Cardiff University with a degree in Journalism and Communications, Ryan earned a NCTJ qualification to further develop as a writer while a Trainee News Writer at Future. 

With contributions from