Do Manchester United have the worst midfield in the Premier League?

FIFA 22
(Image credit: Getty)

The year began with a historic feat at Old Trafford. Just not by Manchester United. It started with an enviably good midfield double act. Just not theirs. As Wolves won away at United for the first time since 1980, it highlighted a difference between them. Rewind a few years and it seemed incongruous that Joao Moutinho and Ruben Neves were Wolves’ duo in the centre. Now the Portuguese pairing are a regular sight and if Moutinho’s goal was a rarity – he is strictly a one-a-season man – and they are a low-scoring side, the twin playmakers can ooze quality when they stroke the ball around. They have an aesthetic appeal. A week later, United prevailed against another Midlands side, but the best central midfielder on the pitch was John McGinn.

Meanwhile, United had Scott McTominay and Nemanja Matic. They were outmanoeuvred and outclassed by their Wolves counterparts; they paled by comparison with McGinn. Each game can tell a different story, and it is worth noting that three days before the Wolves defeat McTominay was outstanding in the defeat of Burnley, just as his usual sidekick Fred had been similarly good when he scored the first goal of the Ralf Rangnick era to defeat Crystal Palace. They are easy to mock and often underestimated, honest triers who, in previous seasons, were willing workers in some notable triumphs over teams with seemingly more talented midfields. Each has proved himself to be a manager’s player.

And yet it is tempting to wonder how many rival sides they would get into, assuming their counterparts were fit and available. Probably not the Wolves side, though Fred would offer more pressing and McTominay greater running power than the 35-year-old Moutinho. Neither is a passer of the same calibre, however, as Neves and Moutinho.

It almost goes without saying that neither would command a place for Manchester City, Chelsea or Liverpool, though Pep Guardiola considered buying Fred before United did and Thomas Tuchel and Jurgen Klopp may see McTominay’s selfless work ethic as a useful attribute in a squad player.

And if United’s objective should be to construct a midfield of the same standard the top three already have, they could come up short against some of their peers in the table now. Take this weekend’s visitors to Old Trafford: put McTominay and Fred in the West Ham squad and there is no chance of either displacing the magnificent Declan Rice. Perhaps one might edge out Tomas Soucek on his form this season, but not if the Czech reached the heights he did last year.

Arsenal? Thomas Partey has been inconsistent but his outstanding performance against City on New Year’s Day illustrated that he has a higher ceiling than either Fred or McTominay. Granit Xhaka’s self-destructive streak means his worst is worse than the United duo’s but as a passer he can knit the game together better than either. 

Tottenham present a comparison of similar figures. Antonio Conte is currently preferring to unite two workhorses, in Pierre-Emile Hojbjerg and Oliver Skipp, benching Harry Winks and Tanguy Ndombele and emphasising graft over craft in a way United ought to recognise. Perhaps Hojbjerg and McTominay could dovetail in a hard-running duo, but they would look short of invention.

The centre of midfield can be an area of strength for Leicester with Wilfred Ndidi and Youri Tielemans, a lovely blend of a destructive and constructive presence. ‘McFred’ may instead end up on Brendan Rodgers’ bench. Even Everton, with Allan and Abdoulaye Doucoure, might struggle to make McTominay or Fred first choices. 

At least one should get in most other sides; indeed McTominay’s athleticism made him the scourge of Leeds last season, so Marcelo Bielsa probably would appreciate him, but each is inferior to Kalvin Phillips. Nor, indeed, should James Ward-Prowse have to worry for his place at Southampton, Conor Gallagher at Crystal Palace, McGinn at Aston Villa or Yves Bissouma for Brighton, were McTominay and Fred to suddenly appear in their squads. 

It is another way of saying that, while they gone around accumulating superstar attackers, United have a mid-table midfield; admittedly, plus Paul Pogba, rarely trusted by Ole Gunnar Solskjaer to play in a deeper duo, and Donny van de Beek, rarely picked at all. ‘McFred’, and the ageing, immobile Matic, may be easy scapegoats but perhaps the greatest scope for improvement in the United team lies in the heart of side. Otherwise, they may have more games when the outstanding midfielder, whether a Neves, a McGinn or a Rice, is in the colours of their opponents.

Subscribe to FourFourTwo today and get three issues for £3.

Restock your kit bag with the best deals for footballers on Amazon right now

ALSO READ

LIST Football Manager 2022: All the FM22 wonderkids you'll need to sign

TALENT FIFA 22: The 150 best wonderkids in the game

GUIDE Best football gifts: Present ideas for football fans

Richard Jolly

Richard Jolly also writes for the National, the Guardian, the Observer, the Straits Times, the Independent, Sporting Life, Football 365 and the Blizzard. He has written for the FourFourTwo website since 2018 and for the magazine in the 1990s and the 2020s, but not in between. He has covered 1500+ games and remembers a disturbing number of the 0-0 draws.

Read more
Ranked! The best central midfielders in the world
Ranked! The 10 best central midfielders in the world
LONDON, ENGLAND - DECEMBER 04: Ruben Amorim Manager / Head Coach of Manchester United stands with Leny Yoro, Marcus Rashford and Joshua Zirkzee as they wait to come on as substitutes during the Premier League match between Arsenal FC and Manchester United FC at Emirates Stadium on December 04, 2024 in London, England. (Photo by Catherine Ivill - AMA/Getty Images)
'I have had enough of that rubbish. I see these boys and I think you're f*cking imposters. Forget the board for a second, who do you start pointing fingers at?' Roy Keane goes on explosive rant over Bruno Fernandes, as Ian Wright challenges him
Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim has signed off on a bizarre transfer at Old Trafford
'The reality is, it's Manchester United in name, the Man United we grew up with and I played against and were giants, is gone': Frosty prediction made amid Manchester United struggles
MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - OCTOBER 30: Matthijs de Ligt of Manchester United controls the ball under pressure from Bilal El Khannouss of Leicester City during the Carabao Cup Fourth Round match between Manchester United and Leicester City at Old Trafford on October 30, 2024 in Manchester, England. (Photo by Nathan Stirk/Getty Images)
‘Manchester United already have the talent at centre-back to climb the table – they just have to protect them with legs in midfield’ Former Old Trafford defender explains how his old club can become consistent again
Ranked! The best defensive midfielders in the world
Ranked! The 10 best defensive midfielders in the world
Tactical explainer: box midfields
The box midfield: football tactics explained
Latest in Stories
Tottenham boss Ange Postecoglou
Tottenham to sack Ange Postecoglou - with London rivals' boss lined up: report
Troy Deeney last played for Forest Green in 2023
Troy Deeney tipped for remarkable football return despite not playing since 2023
Fulham manager Marco Silva looks on from the dugout ahead of the FA Cup fourth round tie against Wigan Athletic at the Brick Community Stadium in Wigan, England on 8 February, 2025
'I think Marco Silva is the best manager in London - he managed to really maintain the desire to play attractive football, which was really hard over the years': Former Fulham talisman showers praise on 'impressive' Marco Silva
Manchester United head coach Ruben Amorim looks on following his side's defeat against AFC Bournemouth
Report reveals 10 Manchester United players leaving this summer
Premier League ball
Quiz! Can you name the players to have scored Premier League hat-tricks?
Jude Bellingham signed terms with adidas in 2024
RANKED! The top 10 Adidas football athletes of 2025
Latest in Features
Orlando Pride players raise the trophy during the NWSL Championship game between Orlando Pride and Washington Spirit at CPKC Stadium on November 23, 2024 in Kansas City, Missouri.
How to watch NWSL: Live streams, TV information for National Women's Soccer League 2025
Premier League ball
Quiz! Can you name the players to have scored Premier League hat-tricks?
Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola holds aloft the Premier League trophy at the Etihad in May 2023.
Quiz! Can you name every Premier League champion... in just 90 seconds?
Barcelona's Spanish midfielder Aitana Bonmati receives the Woman Ballon d'Or award during the 2024 Ballon d'Or France Football award ceremony at the Theatre du Chatelet in Paris on October 28, 2024.
Who are the contenders for the Ballon d'Or Féminin?
 Sheila Garcia of Real Madrid CF battle for the ball with Alessia Russo of Arsenal FC during the UEFA Women's Champions League Quarter Finals First Leg match between Real Madrid CF and Arsenal FC at Estadio Alfredo Di Stefano on March 18, 2025 in Madrid, Spain.
'Over two legs I expected Arsenal to beat Real Madrid in the Champions League, I still think they can despite being 2-0 down,' says former Lioness Izzy Christiansen
Robert Lewandowski of FC Barcelona celebrates scoring his team's first goal with teammates Lamine Yamal and Gavi during the LaLiga match between Sevilla FC and FC Barcelona at Estadio Ramon Sanchez Pizjuan on February 09, 2025 in Seville, Spain.
Watch Barcelona vs Osasuna: Live streams, TV coverage for La Liga clash