Ranked! England's 5 most painful losses ever

England manager Gareth Southgate hugs Bukayo Saka after his penalty miss against Italy in the final of Euro 2020.
England have suffered plenty of painful defeats (Image credit: Getty Images)

England came close to a humiliating defeat and an ignominious early exit at Euro 2024 on Sunday. Trailing 1-0 to Slovakia until the dying moments, the Three Lions needed a stunning Jude Bellingham overhead kick to stay in the tournament.

Harry Kane’s goal in extra-time meant Gareth Southgate’s blushes were spared and the collective outrage was saved for another day. But another humbling loss was uncomfortably close in Gelsenkirchen.

England have, unfortunately, experienced plenty of them over the years. A few have come at major tournaments and left an indelible, traumatising mark on the nation. Here are the most painful of them.

Alan Shearer Explains How England Could Have Won The Euros | FourFourTwo Meets...

5. Croatia 2-1 England, World Cup 2018

Croatia v England | 2018 FIFA World Cup | Match Highlights - YouTube Croatia v England | 2018 FIFA World Cup | Match Highlights - YouTube
Watch On

There was plenty of pain after England’s inspiring run to the semi-finals of the World Cup in 2018 came to an abrupt end at the hands of Croatia. But this was a defeat tinged with hope and optimism, the point, perhaps, at which the future looked brightest under Southgate.

Had England gone on to win Euro 2020, losing to Croatia a few years earlier might have felt more like necessary suffering. But as it is, failing to take the chance to set up a World Cup final against France in Russia still stings.

It all started so well too. Kieran Trippier’s free-kick put England in front after just five minutes and they held that lead until the 68th minute, when Ivan Perisic struck. Mario Mandzukic broke English hearts in extra-time, but there are still fond memories of that summer for Three Lions fans.

4. England 0-0 Portugal (1-3 pens), World Cup 2006

2006 FIFA World Cup Germany™ - Match 59 - Quarter-final - 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England 0 (1) x (3) 0 Portugal 🇵🇹 - YouTube 2006 FIFA World Cup Germany™ - Match 59 - Quarter-final - 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 England 0 (1) x (3) 0 Portugal 🇵🇹 - YouTube
Watch On

As ever, there was plenty of expectation heading into the 2006 World Cup. England looked steady if unspectacular in the group stage, beating Paraguay and Trinidad and Tobago, before a draw with Sweden. 

After edging past Ecuador, Sven-Goran Eriksson’s side faced Portugal in the quarter-finals. Had they been beaten convincingly, it might well have felt less miserable. First, David Beckham went off with an injury and then Wayne Rooney was sent off for a stamp on Ricardo Carvalho.

England managed to stay in the game for 120 minutes, but were beaten in the penalty shootout with two of their most influential players watching on from the sidelines. Again, it was a case of what might have been.

3. England 1-2 Iceland, Euro 2016

England vs Iceland 1 2 All Goals & Highlights Elimination EURO 2016 HD YouTube - YouTube England vs Iceland 1 2 All Goals & Highlights Elimination EURO 2016 HD YouTube - YouTube
Watch On

Defeat to minnows Iceland is often referenced as the nadir in modern English football, the point at which things could get no worse. It spelled the end of Roy Hodgson’s difficult reign and highlighted the need for significant change.

Things have gotten better since, but eight years on the Iceland loss remains a chastening one. All appeared to be going to plan when Rooney converted a penalty after four minutes, only for the underdogs to strike back immediately through Ragnar Sigurdsson. Twelve minutes later, Kolbeinn Sigthorsson made it 2-1.

And that was how it stayed. The thunderous viking claps of the Iceland fans would have been ringing in the England players’ ears as they left France with their tails between their legs.

2. Argentina 2-1 England, World Cup 1986

Argentina 2-1 England World Cup 1986 | Full highlight | 1080p HD - Diego Maradona - YouTube Argentina 2-1 England World Cup 1986 | Full highlight | 1080p HD - Diego Maradona - YouTube
Watch On

Time is the greatest healer, supposedly, but those who lived through England’s defeat to Argentina at the 1986 World Cup might disagree. The rivalry with Argentina made things tense enough ahead of a much anticipated quarter-final at Estadio Azteca.

And it didn’t disappoint for the neutral. Diego Maradona stole the headlines with his “Hand of God” goal, a brilliantly-concealed punch past Peter Shilton. He followed that up with the “Goal of the Century”, an astonishing solo run from his own half to give Argentina victory.

The infuriating genius of Maradona only added to the hurt for England, who felt both aggrieved and heartbroken. On another day, things might have gone very differently.

1. England 1-1 Italy (2-3 pens), Euro 2020

HIGHLIGHTS | More penalty pain for England as Italy win Euro 2020 - YouTube HIGHLIGHTS | More penalty pain for England as Italy win Euro 2020 - YouTube
Watch On

Recency bias, perhaps, but the most painful defeat of them all has to be the agonising penalty-shootout loss to Italy in the Euro 2020 final. A Wembley crowd that had been ready to celebrate were stunned into silence when Bukayo Saka missed the decisive spot-kick.

England, throughout the summer, had looked on course for something special, for a first major tournament success since 1966. They beat Germany at a raucous Wembley, overcame a stubborn Denmark and then faced Italy on home soil in the final.

But the fine margins went the other way again, and England were left to mourn another painful loss.

More England stories

England manager Gareth Southgate's three changes for Switzerland clash laid out by Alan Shearer

What is England’s record against Switzerland?

Am I going mad or is Phil Foden England's obvious problem right now?

Callum Rice-Coates

Callum is a football writer who has had work published by the likes of BBC Sport, the Independent, BT Sport and the Blizzard, amongst various others. A lifelong Wrexham fan, he is hoping Ryan Reynolds can lead his hometown club to the promised land.

Read more
STUTTGART, GERMANY - JUNE 12: England manager Bobby Robson looks on before the 1988 European Championships match between England and Republic of Ireland at Neckarstadion on June 12, 1988 in Stuttgart, Germany. (Photo by Allsport/Getty Images)
Ranked! EVERY England manager ranked from worst to best
Bukayo Saka celebrates with Harry Kane after scoring for England against North Macedonia in June 2023.
Players who scored hat-tricks for England
Frank Lampard of England takes his penalty which was saved by Ricardo of Portugal in a penalty shootout during the FIFA World Cup Germany 2006 Quarter-final match between England and Portugal played at the Stadium Gelsenkirchen on July 1, 2006 in Gelsenkirchen, Germany.
Quiz! Can you name the 100 most-capped England players since 1966?
13 October 1993 Rotterdam, World Cup Qualifying match, Netherlands v England, Ronald Koeman scores a goal from a free kick. (Photo by Mark Leech/Offside via Getty Images)
‘Yes, Ronald Koeman should have been sent off against England in 1993, but David Platt also could have stayed on his feet – that’s never mentioned’ Former Three Lions star on playing in one of the country’s most infamous matches
Wigan Athletic's Barbadian defender Emmerson Boyce (L) and Wigan Athletic's Scottish defender Gary Caldwell (R) raise the FA Cup after winning the English FA Cup final football match between Manchester City and Wigan Athletic at Wembley Stadium in London on May 11, 2013. Substitute Ben Watson scored an injury-time winner to give Wigan Athletic a sensational 1-0 win over Manchester City at Wembley Stadium on Saturday in the biggest FA Cup final upset in 25 years. AFP PHOTO / ANDREW YATES NOT FOR MARKETING OR ADVERTISING USE / RESTRICTED TO EDITORIAL USE (Photo credit should read ANDREW YATES/AFP via Getty Images)
Ranked! The 27 greatest cup shocks in English football history
Gareth Southgate smiling
RANKED! The 10 best English managers in football right now
Latest in Stories
Manchester City manager Pep Guardiola is expected to sanction plenty of sales this summer
When does the summer transfer window open?
Arne Slot and Mikel Arteta could both do with improving their respective attacks this summer
Arsenal to make bold move for Liverpool star with uncertain Anfield future: report
LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 21: Phil Foden of England reacts during the FIFA World Cup 2026 European Qualifier between England and Albania at Wembley Stadium on March 21, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Eddie Keogh - The FA/The FA via Getty Images)
'When I see Phil Foden play, he just seems like a shy lad - that holds him back a little bit. He has been tried in every position, but he just hasn’t performed': Ex-England star makes bold claim about Manchester City man
Arsenal's William Saliba and Gabriel Magalhaes embrace each other in celebration at full-time of the Premier League match against Wolverhampton Wanderers at Molineux on 25 January, 2025
Arsenal face losing Gabriel AND William Saliba, as new fears arise: report
Kevin De Bruyne of Man City in action during the Premier League match between Manchester City FC and Ipswich Town FC at Etihad Stadium on August 24, 2024 in Manchester, England.
Kevin De Bruyne touted for shock move to South American giants: report
LEVERKUSEN, GERMANY - MAY 18: Jose Mourinho, Head Coach of AS Roma, celebrates after the UEFA Europa League semi-final second leg match between Bayer 04 Leverkusen and AS Roma at BayArena on May 18, 2023 in Leverkusen, Germany. (Photo by Lars Baron/Getty Images)
Jose Mourinho planning Premier League raid for superstar: report
Latest in News
Arne Slot and Mikel Arteta could both do with improving their respective attacks this summer
Arsenal to make bold move for Liverpool star with uncertain Anfield future: report
LONDON, ENGLAND - MARCH 21: Phil Foden of England reacts during the FIFA World Cup 2026 European Qualifier between England and Albania at Wembley Stadium on March 21, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Eddie Keogh - The FA/The FA via Getty Images)
'When I see Phil Foden play, he just seems like a shy lad - that holds him back a little bit. He has been tried in every position, but he just hasn’t performed': Ex-England star makes bold claim about Manchester City man
Arsenal's William Saliba and Gabriel Magalhaes embrace each other in celebration at full-time of the Premier League match against Wolverhampton Wanderers at Molineux on 25 January, 2025
Arsenal face losing Gabriel AND William Saliba, as new fears arise: report
Kevin De Bruyne of Man City in action during the Premier League match between Manchester City FC and Ipswich Town FC at Etihad Stadium on August 24, 2024 in Manchester, England.
Kevin De Bruyne touted for shock move to South American giants: report
LEVERKUSEN, GERMANY - MAY 18: Jose Mourinho, Head Coach of AS Roma, celebrates after the UEFA Europa League semi-final second leg match between Bayer 04 Leverkusen and AS Roma at BayArena on May 18, 2023 in Leverkusen, Germany. (Photo by Lars Baron/Getty Images)
Jose Mourinho planning Premier League raid for superstar: report
Jack Grealish
Manchester City report: Jack Grealish poised for European switch, with price revealed