Ranked! Every Premier League kit this season, from worst to best

20. Newcastle United home

Joelinton celebrates his assist for Newcastle United vs Manchester City in the League Cup

Joelinton in the Newcastle United home shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Getty Images)

They ended on a high, at least. Castore's final Newcastle shirt is high-class indeed; the stripes perfectly weighted, the collar finely detailed and the cuffs matching. No bright shades interfering. No nasty betting sponsor. 100 per cent, pure Geordie loveliness. 

Castore won't be missed by many but if Newcastle have a good season, this may well become a classic. And that wouldn't be a bad thing by a long chalk. 

19. Luton Town third

Luton Town third kit

Luton Town third kit for 23/24 (Image credit: Luton Town)

Make jokes about Derby's piddly points total, about Carlton Morris sounding like your dad's first car (credit: FFT deputy ed Matthew Ketchell), about the Kenny… and about orange being a colour that simply belongs in the Championship.

It's water off a duck's back when you see this top. It's just cold. It is Premier League quality, come what may this season. Umbro have excelled – and we hope the Hatters pick up a fair few points on the road donning this absolute beauty.

18. Tottenham Hotspur home

Son Heung-min and James Maddison celebrate after combining to score for Tottenham against Arsenal at the Emirates Stadium in September 2023.

Son Heung-min and James Maddison wearing the Tottenham home shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Getty Images)

It's simple, it's sophisticated and the all-over pattern looks decent. We commend Nike for this one: Tottenham's Big Ange era looks wavy already. 

Because it's so hard to reinvent the wheel when it comes to the white home shirt: to constantly reconfigure spokes, adding in a collar, changing the thick navy lining to thin navy lining, moving to volt flourishes, then removing them for something a little more stripped back. Let's be real here: this might be the best Tottenham home shirt that the brand has ever delivered. 

17. Manchester City home

Manchester City star Erling Haaland carries the matchball after scoring a hat-trick during the Premier League match between Manchester City and Fulham FC at Etihad Stadium on September 02, 2023 in Manchester, England.

Erling Haaland in the Manchester City home shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Lewis Storey/Getty Images)

This one is Puma at their best: it's not just when they innovate, it's when they create something unique. 

Not just a smart piece of kit, it's a slap in the face of anyone who tells you City have no history, with this shirt marking two decades of the Etihad with its cute, turret-like stripes on the shirt. It looks like the ground and it evokes the exact top from 20 years ago: it's ingenious and only City could wear it. Three judges agreed marking it 8, 8 and 8.5.

16. Everton home

Hummel Everton home shirt 23/24

James Tarkowski in the Everton home shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Hummel/Everton)

This might be Hummel's best-ever Everton home shirt, by the way.

The collar is fancy enough as it is but when you look closely, the Goodison Park architectural patterning adorns the design. And that's the top: no frills, no flourishes, no bright base pattern or other garish gimmicks. A classic home shirt all around. 

15. Brighton & Hove Albion home

Brighton vs West Ham live stream Kaoru Mitoma of Brighton & Hove Albion celebrates after scoring the team's first goal during the Premier League match between Wolverhampton Wanderers and Brighton & Hove Albion at Molineux on August 19, 2023 in Wolverhampton, England

Kaoru Mitoma and Pervis Estupinan in the Brighton home shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Getty Images)

Brighton have toyed with red as a colour on their shirt to add flair; last year, it was a bright, sunny yellow. This year, it's basic Brighton: blue and white all over. And it look epic. 

The raglan sleeves and even number of stripes across the chest give this one a particularly contemporary look: the Seagulls are going to look great wearing this in Europe. 

14. Manchester United home

Irene Guerrero of Manchester United Women poses after signing for the club at Old Trafford on September 14, 2023 in Manchester, England

Irene Guerrero in the Manchester United home shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Getty Images)

How United reached the fourth decade of the Premier League before adding the famous Manchester rose to their shirts, we'll never know. A geometric pattern was always going to be the coolest way to go.

The amount of black on this one reinstates the meanness that counteracts a flower, with a nice collar and improved sponsor logo. Manchester United home shirts aren't always hits but this one certainly is. 

13. Fulham third

Tim Ream of Fulham during the Premier League match between Manchester City and Fulham FC at Etihad Stadium on September 2, 2023 in Manchester, England.

Tim Ream in the Fulham third shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Matthew Ashton - AMA/Getty Images)

Fulham embraced a Barbie aesthetic for their away shirt. For the third, they've incorporated a much more paletable pink.

David Beckham would be more than happy to sign this off as an Inter Miami strip. The black/pink combination is a winner, with added hexagonal line-work to boot. Straightforward and smashing from the west Londoners. 

12. Bournemouth away

Bournemouth kit

The Bournemouth away kit for 23/24 (Image credit: Bournemouth)

Umbro have done a great job appropriating Bournemouth the town in recent change shirts. They delivered a beautiful, bright blue effort which evoked the pier in 2020/21, while the Cherries' away shirt last season was purple and patterned with palm trees similar to those down the road in Sandbanks.

Once again, Andoni Iraola's men have a seaside-inspired strip, this time with a simple wavy pattern across the torso over a pale blue base. It feels like a defining away shirt for the club already. 

11. Wolves third

Mario Lemina of Wolverhampton Wanderers poses for a portrait in the Wolverhampton Wanderers 2023/24 Third Kit on July 23, 2023 in Faro, Portugal.

Mario Lemina in the Wolverhampton Wanderers third shirt for 23/24 (Image credit: Jack Thomas - WWFC/Wolves via Getty Images)

This is more like it. While Wolves' other two shirts look like they simply wish to sit at the back of the club's superstore next to the novelty mugs, unassuming and away from the glare, the third kit is having none of it.

Sky blue with white and navy touches, this one begs to be adored – and you know what? We do. Five of us scored it a 7 or above. 

Mark White
Content Editor

Mark White is the Digital Content Editor at FourFourTwo. During his time on the brand, Mark has written three cover features on Mikel Arteta, Martin Odegaard and the Invincibles, and has written pieces on subjects ranging from Sir Bobby Robson’s time at Barcelona to the career of Robinho. An encyclopedia of football trivia and collector of shirts, he first joined the team back in 2020 as a staff writer.