Ranked! The 10 best League Cup finals ever

Birmingham City's Obafemi Martins and Nikola Zigic celebrate the winning goal against Arsenal in the 2011 League Cup final
(Image credit: Getty Images)

What are the best League Cup finals ever?

Ones that include plenty of drama and goals, of course. But everyone also loves a giant-killing. Except fans of the giant, of course. 

While neither Liverpool nor Chelsea can be classed as an underdog for this year's final, what the game could give us is plenty of action - something this competition hasn’t exactly been short of over the years. From overhead winners to 330-minute-long tussles, managers shushing fans to penalty heroics, this selection of cup finals should whet your appetite for Sunday...

10. Luton 3-2 Arsenal, 1988

Luton Town celebrating winning the 1988 League Cup final

Luton Town celebrating winning the 1988 League Cup final (Image credit: Getty Images)

Despite competing in the same division as their opponents at the time, Luton were considered massive underdogs when they faced George Graham’s defending League Cup champions at Wembley.

Brian Stein’s goal gave Town a shock lead, but two strikes in three minutes after the break from Martin Hayes and Alan Smith put the Gunners in charge. When they won an 80th-minute penalty, the game looked dead as a contest.

Instead, Nigel Winterburn’s effort from 12 yards was saved and the Hatters roared back as Danny Wilson levelled with a header, before Stein secured Luton’s only major honour with a last-minute winner.

9. Tottenham 2-1 Chelsea, 2008

Tottenham Hotspur's English footballer Jonathan Woodgate (R) scores past Chelsea goalkeeper Petr Cech in extra time during the Carling Cup Final match at Wembley Stadium, north London, England, on February 24, 2008. AFP PHOTO/GLYN KIRK Mobile and website use of domestic English football pictures are subject to obtaining a Photographic End User Licence from Football DataCo Ltd Tel : +44 (0) 207 864 9121 or e-mail accreditations@football-dataco.com - applies to Premier and Football League matches (Photo credit should read GLYN KIRK/AFP via Getty Images)

Tottenham's Jonathan Woodgate scores the winner against Chelsea in 2008 (Image credit: Getty Images)

With the 2008 final in extra-time, in the first League Cup game played at the new Wembley, Jonathan Woodgate stepped up to hand Tottenham their first - and to date, only - trophy in the 21st century. 

Juande Ramos' stuttering Spurs overcame Chelsea in London that day, despite going behind in the first half to a Didier Drogba free-kick. Dimitar Berbatov's penalty took the game into extra-time, though, helping Woodgate become the Tottenham hero.

A helping hand from Petr Cech ensured he got his head on the ball, and despite Ramos lasting just eight more months in charge, he'll be remembered for handing the club their most-recent trophy. 

8. Aston Villa 3-2 Everton, 1977 (second replay)

Aston Villa players unfurl a celebratory banner after finally winning the 1977 League Cup

Aston Villa players unfurl a celebratory banner after finally winning the 1977 League Cup (Image credit: Getty Images)

Third time lucky. Villa and Everton had played out two dull draws in their first couple of attempts at deciding the League Cup, but rewarded fans at Old Trafford for their patience in the second replay.

Bob Latchford put the Toffees in front before an incredible 40-yard strike from Chris Nicholl levelled things. Brian Little then nudged Villa ahead but Mick Lyons quickly responded to equalise with the third goal of a mad four-minute period.

The teams were finally separated after 330 minutes of deadlock, however, when Little nicked it with his second goal of the game a minute before the end of extra time.

7. Liverpool 1-1 Birmingham (5-4 on pens), 2001

Liverpool's Jamie Carragher scores in the 2001 League Cup final penalty shootout

Liverpool's Jamie Carragher scores in the 2001 League Cup final penalty shootout (Image credit: Getty Images)

The first of Liverpool's cup treble in 2001 came in the first major football final to be played at the Millennium Stadium in Cardiff, as the Reds squeezed past Birmingham on penalties to land their first piece of silverware in six years.

Robbie Fowler had put Liverpool ahead in normal time, with Gerard Houlier's side seemingly comfortable in seeing the game out against the second-tier opposition. In the 90th-minute, though, Birmingham were awarded a penalty, with centre-back Darren Purse leathering the ball past Sander Westerveld in the Liverpool goal.

Unfortunately, Blues' penalty luck ran out in the shootout, as a young Andy Johnson missed the decisive kick that handed Liverpool the crown. The 2001 League Cup final was dramatic, and will forever be remembered for the first major English final to be decided by a shootout.

6. Nottingham Forest 3-2 Southampton, 1979

Nottingham Forest striker Garry Birtles, 9, has scored their second goal as Archie Gemmill celebrates

Nottingham Forest striker Garry Birtles, 9, has scored their second goal as Archie Gemmill celebrates (Image credit: Getty Images)

It’s fair to say Nottingham Forest were in a good place going into their final clash with Southampton. They were defending champions, league champions and 4-1 up midway through their two-legged European Cup quarter-final – a competition they would go on to win.

However, the night before this game, Brian Clough encouraged his players to see off a crate of champagne after some mild boozy success against Liverpool earlier in the season, but it showed as they trudged in at half-time 1-0 down to David Peach’s goal.

They soon took control as Garry Birtles struck twice and Tony Woodcock added another, though, making Nick Holmes’s late goal for Saints nothing more than a consolation.

5. Chelsea 3-2 Liverpool, 2005

CARDIFF, United Kingdom: Chelsea's captain John Terry holds up the Carling Cup trophy with his teammates after defeating Liverpool in the Carling Cup Final football match at the Millennium Dome in Cardiff, Wales, 27 February, 2005. Chelsea won 3-2 in extra time. AFP PHOTO/REBECCA NADEN NO TELCOS, WEBSITES SUBJECT TO SUBCRIPTION OF LICENCE WITH FAPL AT WWW.FAPLWEB.COM (Photo credit should read REBECCA NADEN/AFP via Getty Images)

Terry lifts the League Cup trophy in 2005 (Image credit: Getty Images)

Jose Mourinho's love of the League Cup started in 2005, as he won his Chelsea trophy as manager against a Liverpool side full of character. However, things didn't start quite as the Portuguese would have imagined, with John Arne Riise putting Liverpool ahead inside a minute of the first whistle. 

As Chelsea chased an equaliser, Steven Gerrard suffered heartbreak as he scored an own goal to level the scores and send the game into extra-time - though not before Mourinho had sprinted down the touchline and told Liverpool fans to be quiet through a 'shush' gesture. Inevitably, he received a red card, but that didn't dampen his spirits as Didier Drogba and Mateja Kezman stepped up in extra-time to hand Chelsea the win.

Antonio Nunez – remember him? – got a consolation for Liverpool.

4. Birmingham 2-1 Arsenal, 2011

Birmingham City's Obafemi Martins (2ndR) celebrates with teammates after scoring during the Carling Cup final football match between Arsenal and Birmingham at the Wembley Stadium in London on February 27, 2011. AFP PHOTO/GLYN KIRKFOR EDITORIAL USE ONLY Additional licence required for any commercial/promotional use or use on TV or internet (except identical online version of newspaper) of Premier League/Football League photos. Tel DataCo +44 207 2981656. Do not alter/modify photo. (Photo credit should read GLYN KIRK/AFP via Getty Images)

Birmingham's Obafemi Martins celebrates scoring the winner against Arsenal in the 2011 League Cup final (Image credit: Getty Images)

Nothing other than an Arsenal victory seemed possible at Wembley in 2011, as a Samir Nasri and Robin van Persie-led Gunners side looked to deliver a hammer blow to relegation strugglers Birmingham City. Having not won a trophy in six years, Arsenal fans were ready to celebrate success once more.

Things didn't quite go to plan, however, as the towering Nikola Zigic nodded Birmingham in front. It took just ten minutes for Van Persie to level the scores, but an inspired performance from Ben Foster ensured the Dutchman wouldn't celebrate anymore over the rest of the game.

Disaster then struck for Arsenal, as Obafemi Martins latched onto a loose ball that Laurent Koscielny and Wojciech Szczesny failed to deal with in the box. The Nigerian made no mistake in finding the back of the net from just yards out, sending Blues fans into pandemonium. 

Birmingham were relegated just three months later, but their first trophy since 1963 was a major sweetener.

3. Swindon 3-1 Arsenal, 1969

Swindon's Rod Thomas tackles Arsenal's Bobby Gould in the 1969 League Cup final

Swindon's Rod Thomas tackles Arsenal's Bobby Gould in the 1969 League Cup final (Image credit: Getty Images)

In a game that scarred young Nick Hornby for life, Swindon stunned Arsenal with another shock result just two years after third-tier QPR had humiliated top-flight West Brom.

Roger Smart sprang onto a loose backpass to put the minnows in front, and they defended their lead until Bobby Gould found an equaliser with four minutes remaining.

It was time for a hero and Don Rogers stepped up for Swindon, scoring twice to complete an afternoon beyond their fans’ wildest dreams. Arsenal went on to blame the flu and a heavy pitch, but nobody was listening.

2. Manchester City 2-1 Newcastle, 1976

Manchester City's Dennis Tueart scores the winning goal for City in the 1976 League Cup final with a spectacular overhead kick

Manchester City's Dennis Tueart scores the winning goal for City in the 1976 League Cup final with a spectacular overhead kick (Image credit: Getty Images)

Forever remembered for Dennis Tueart’s stunning overhead-kick winner, the '76 final featured two sides desperate to end their trophy droughts. 

Peter Barnes put City ahead in the first half, before Alan Gowling levelled things. And so it was up to Tueart, a boyhood Newcastle fan, to pull a rabbit out of the hat with a memorable strike.

Tony Book became the first person to win the trophy as both player and manager, while the triumph remained City’s last until 2011.

1. QPR 3-2 West Brom, 1967

Queens Park Rangers players celebrate with the League Cup with their captain Mike Keen

Queens Park Rangers players celebrate with the League Cup with their captain Mike Keen (Image credit: Getty Images)

The 1967 League Cup final is an historic one, for a number of reasons. 

Firstly, it was the first to be hosted at Wembley since the competition's inception in 1960, while it also scrapped the two-legged format that did little to increase the spectacle. Most importantly, though, is that third-tier side QPR emerged as the winners, basking in their underdog status on the hallowed turf of the national stadium.

They didn't make it easy for themselves, either. West Brom raced into a two-goal lead by half-time thanks to Clive Clark’s double, but Roger Morgan reduced the deficit. It got even better for QPR as Rodney Marsh and the suitably named Mike Lazarus netted to complete a remarkable fightback, and give headline writers an easy day’s work.

Alasdair Mackenzie is a freelance journalist based in Rome, and a FourFourTwo contributor since 2015. When not pulling on the FFT shirt, he can be found at Reuters, The Times and the i. An Italophile since growing up on a diet of Football Italia on Channel 4, he now counts himself among thousands of fans sharing a passion for Ross County and Lazio. 

With contributions from