‘Bryan Robson took us to Florida to unwind before 2005’s Great Escape, then results changed’ to this day Robert Earnshaw admits he has no idea how West Brom avoided relegation 20 years ago having been bottom at Christmas

 West Bromwich Albion Fans celebrate on the pitch after avoiding relegation at the Premier League match between West Bromwich Albion and Portsmouth at The Hawthorns on May 15, 2005 in West Bromwich, England.
West Brom fans celebrate history on the final day of the 2004/05 season (Image credit: Future)

Only four clubs have managed it, but Bryan Robson’s West Brom side of 2004/05 were the first to survive relegation, having been bottom at Christmas. Rob Earnshaw played a significant role in this historic feat, contributing 11 league goals in 18 starts for the beleaguered Baggies.

“I still don’t know how we pulled it off!” admits Earnshaw, 20 years on speaking to FourFourTwo. “The manager who signed me, Gary Megson, was sacked halfway through a difficult season.

“Nobody had ever stayed up after being rock-bottom at Christmas, but that motivated us. We had nothing to lose.”

Survival Sunday

Robert Earnshaw of WBA celebrates at the end of the Barclays Premiership match between West Bromwich Albion and Portsmouth at The Hawthorns on May 15, 2005 in Birmingham, England

Robert Earnshaw was West Brom's top scorer during their great escape season (Image credit: Getty Images)

For the first time since the inaugural Premier League season in 1992–93, no team was assured of relegation going into the final day of the 2004/05 season. West Brom kicked off their game at home to Portsmouth (who were on 39 points but safe from relegation themselves) rock bottom.

Southampton and Crystal Palace were one point ahead of them with Norwich City in the last safe spot, two points from the bottom. Only one would stay up on what Sky Sports branded: ‘Survival Sunday'.

Kevin Campbell pours champagne over Bryan Robson of WBA after securing premiership status at the end of the Barclays Premiership match between West Bromwich Albion and Portsmouth at The Hawthorns on May 15, 2005 in Birmingham, England.

Was a team bonding trip to America the catalyst for West Brom's historic great escape (Image credit: Getty Images)

West Brom at one stage had been eight points adrift from safety. But they did their part by beating Portsmouth 2–0. Norwich were the only side to have their fate completely in their own hands.

They required a first away victory of the season at Craven Cottage vs Fulham which would relegate everyone else in the process. Instead, they were thrashed 6–0 and went down.

Southampton, despite leading early on, lost 2–1 at home to Manchester United and were relegated. Meanwhile, at The Valley, Crystal Palace led Charlton Athletic 2–1 in the 71st minute, but Jonathan Fortune equalised for Charlton with eight minutes left and the Saints dropped.

West Brom survived and made history by becoming the first club in Premier League history to avoid relegation after being bottom of the table at Christmas. As all four fixtures ended Sky’s cameras focused on the Hawthorns.

A traditional last-day-of-the-season pitch invasion was underway with Portsmouth fans in the away end joining in celebrations as through losing, they had helped relegate arch-rivals Southampton. Reflecting on the season two decades on, Earnshaw pinpoints a mid-season bonding trip to America as the moment the tide turned for West Brom.

“During a 10-day break without a game, Bryan Robson took us to Florida to get away from it all, which was refreshing. We got together as a team and bonded.

“From then on, results changed. We earned a draw at Old Trafford in our penultimate game and beat Portsmouth at home on the final day. It was a miracle. We had no right to do it, but we really believed in ourselves and showed that we could.”

Twenty seasons later Southampton are the latest club to have been bottom of the table at Christmas. Stats site Opta forecasts their chances of being relegated at 97.8%. In the 19 seasons since West Brom first managed it, only three clubs have managed the great escape.

Swipe to scroll horizontally
Teams bottom of the league on Christmas Day
YearTeamOutcome
1992Nottingham Forest22nd (relegated)
1993Swindon Town22nd (relegated)
1994Ipswich Town22nd (relegated)
1995Bolton Wanderers20th (relegated)
1996Nottingham Forest20th (relegated)
1997Barnsley19th (relegated)
1998Nottingham Forest20th (relegated)
1999Sheffield Wednesday19th (relegated)
2000Bradford City20th (relegated)
2001Ipswich Town18th (relegated)
2002West Ham18th (relegated)
2003Wolves20th (relegated)
2004West Brom17th (survived)
2005Sunderland20th (relegated)
2006Watford20th (relegated)
2007Derby County20th (relegated)
2008West Brom20th (relegated)
2009Portsmouth20th (relegated)
2010West Ham20th (relegated)
2011Blackburn Rovers19th (relegated)
2012Reading19th (relegated)
2013Sunderland14th (survived)
2014Leicester City14th (survived)
2015Aston Villa20th (relegated)
2016Hull City18th (relegated)
2017Swansea City18th (relegated)
2018Fulham19th (relegated)
2019Watford19th (relegated)
2020Sheffield United20th (relegated)
2021Norwich City20th (relegated)
2022Wolves13th (survived)
2023Sheffield United20th (relegated)
Matthew Ketchell
Deputy Editor

A former goalkeeper, Ketch joined FourFourTwo as Deputy Editor in 2022 having worked across ChronicleLive, LeedsLive, Hull Daily Mail, YorkshireLive, Teesside Gazette and the Huddersfield Examiner as a Northern Football Editor. Prior to that he was the Senior Writer at BBC Match of the Day magazine. He has interviewed the likes of Harry Kane, Trent Alexander-Arnold, Gareth Southgate and attended two World Cup finals and two Champions League finals. He has been a Newcastle United season ticket holder since 2000 and has a deep knowledge on the history and culture of football shirts.

With contributions from