‘Early on, Shearer was quite rightly the main man, but being backup really grinded on me as the years wore on – I hated the role’: Newcastle United cult hero reveals annoyance at never being considered good enough for No.9 role at St. James' Park

NEWCASTLE, UNITED KINGDOM: Newcastle's Alan Shearer (R) celebrates with Shola Ameobi (L) and Laurent Robert (C) after scoring against SC Heerenveen to make it 2-0 during their UEFA Cup football match at St James' Park in Newcastle, 24 February 2005. AFP PHOTO Paul Barker (Photo credit should read PAUL BARKER/AFP via Getty Images)
Newcastle strikers Alan Shearer and Shola Ameobi (Image credit: Getty Images)

Newcastle United striker Alan Shearer was still at the peak of his powers at the turn of the millennium, with the England striker hitting 95 goals across five seasons between 1999 and 2004.

By 2000, Shola Ameobi was breaking into the Newcastle first team as an 18-year-old, learning from the best. He started 12 consectuive games in the 2000/01 season as main strikers Alan Shearer and Carl Cort were both out injured, and looked a great prospect for the future at St. James' Park.

The 2003/04 campaign is where Ameobi truly managed to get a run of games starting in a Newcastle shirt, but his lack of goals ultimately started seeing other strikers preferred ahead of him. While Ameobi never expected to start ahead of Shearer, he did feel like he deserved more opportunities to prove his worth in the starting XI.

Newcastle United substitute status 'grinded' on Ameobi

Shola Ameobi of Newcastle United celebrates after scoring a goal against West Bromwich Albion, 2006

Ameobi celebrates at Newcastle (Image credit: Alamy)

"Early on, Shearer was quite rightly the main man, and I suppose I accepted the fact I was backup to him and Bellamy and that I’d be a sub more often than not," Ameobi admits to FourFourTwo.

"In Premier League history, only three or four players have made more substitute appearances than me – but do you know something? I hated the role. It really grinded on me."

As the former striker highlights, only James Milner, Peter Crouch, Shane Long and Jermaine Defoe have more substitute appearances than Ameobi in the Premier League.

Alan Shearer celebrates a goal for Newcastle United against Dynamo Kyiv in October 2002.

Ameobi couldn't dislodge Shearer from the team (Image credit: Getty Images)

"I’m seen as being quite a laid-back guy, but I can tell you that after three or four years, I had a number of chats with various bosses about my role," Ameobi adds. "I wasn’t afraid to tell them that I felt I wasn’t getting the opportunities I deserved.

"Don’t get me wrong: I never thought I should be ahead of Alan. But as the years wore on, I considered myself a first-team player and tried to make my case whenever I needed to."

In total, Ameobi came off the bench 142 times in England's top flight, while he started 170. In those appearances he bagged 79 goals, a figure that is certainly a gripe he has from his career.

Ameobi never actually managed to hit double figures in a Premier League season, and when asked if he was prolific enough in front of goal, Ameobi is unequivocal in his answer.

VIDEO: Why Thomas Tuchel Is PERFECT For England

"No," he admits. "When I look at my career [league] record and see ‘70’ alongside my name, I realise that it should have been more. I really don’t like that stat.

"In my defence, I was never an out-and-out goalscorer – my game was as much about assists, bringing team-mates into play and decoy runs as putting the ball in the net. But I definitely wasn’t as ruthless as I should have been. I never had that killer instinct and selfishness of a natural striker.

"I heard Alan say recently that he’d rather score a hat-trick in a 4-3 loss than walk off goalless after a 1-0 win. That wasn’t me."

Ryan Dabbs
Staff writer

Ryan is a staff writer for FourFourTwo, joining the team full-time in October 2022. He first joined Future in December 2020, working across FourFourTwo, Golf Monthly, Rugby World and Advnture's websites, before eventually earning himself a position with FourFourTwo permanently. After graduating from Cardiff University with a degree in Journalism and Communications, Ryan earned a NCTJ qualification to further develop as a writer while a Trainee News Writer at Future. 

With contributions from