‘I messed up by offering to take Germany’s fifth penalty at Euro 96. It was the most pressure I ever felt - and I still have Gareth Southgate's shirt!’

German team captain Juergen Klinsmann (up) celebrates with Stefan Kuntz at the end of the Euro96 soccer championship final against the Czech Republic, 30 June 1996. Germany won 2-1 with a golden goal in extra time by Oliver Bierhoff.
Klinsmann and Kuntz celebrate at Euro 96 (Image credit: Getty Images)

Putting your hand up to take a penalty with a place in the final of a major tournament on the line is one of the bolder things a footballer can do. You’re expected to score, but should you be the player who misses the vital spot kick, it can even be a career-defining moment. 

While Gareth Southgate has enjoyed a fruitful second act as the most successful England manager of modern times, his playing career was forever blighted by his Euro 96 shootout miss. Southgate’s miss came after ten penalties had been duly dispatched as the Germans lived up to their reputation as mentality masters, amid England nerves.

This contrasting mentality and the confidence of the Germans was underlined by Stefan Kuntz, who took the penalty before Southgate’s fateful spot kick, knowing that had he missed, it would have all been over. That’s because when Kuntz volunteered to take Germany’s fifth penalty, he assumed the shootout wouldn’t have even got that far.

VIDEO: Why Germany Have Been The Best Team At Euro 2024 (So Far)

“I messed up a little bit with the shootout,” Kuntz tells FourFourTwo. “I didn’t think England would take a fifth penalty – I thought it would be over by that point – so I offered to take that one for Germany. England scored their fifth, which left me needing to score. It was the most pressure of my entire career.

Honestly, we felt it too! I’m just happy it went in.” Interstingly, both Kuntz and Southgate were appointed as their respective nations’ Under-21 managers after they hung up their boots, meaning they have had the chance to reminisce about that night at the old Wembley Stadium.

“Yes, Gareth and I have met quite a few times” he adds. “I took his shirt after that match at Wembley and I still have it. When we met again, I told him that and agreed to give him one of my old ones the next time we met, which I did.”

Gareth Southgate after missing his penalty against Germany during the Euro 96 semi-final

Gareth Southgate after missing his penalty against Germany during the Euro 96 semi-final (Image credit: PA)

Get a free live stream to watch Euro 2024 from anywhere in the world ahead of the summer's big tournament

More Euro 96 stories

‘I didn’t see the ball move, but I remember reading all that Uri Geller nonsense’ Alan Shearer wishes as many people remembered his Euro 96 goal vs Scotland as they did the ‘phenomenon’ behind Gary McAllister’s penalty miss

Terry Venables' Euro 96 masterclass: How England were ahead of the curve

‘My mum asked why Baddiel and Skinner wore my shirt in their Three Lions video – I didn’t have the heart to tell her why our surname is so funny’: German star on being a part of English football culture

Joe Mewis

For more than a decade Joe Mewis has worked in football journalism as a reporter and editor, with stints at Mirror Football and LeedsLive among others. He is the author of four football history books that include times on Leeds United and the England national team.

With contributions from