Anthony Martial leaving, with new creator joining: Manchester United's dream January transfer window

Manchester United's manager Erik Ten Hag prior to kick off during the Emirates FA Cup Fourth Round match between Newport County and Manchester United at Rodney Parade on January 28, 2024 in Newport, Wales.
(Image credit: Getty Images)

As ever, speculation is rife as to the transfer activity of Manchester United this January.

There have already been some loan departures away from Old Trafford, most notable among them Jadon Sancho’s return to Borussia Dortmund, but the Red Devils are yet to sign anyone.

Erik ten Hag’s side sit eighth in the Premier League in what has been another turbulent campaign to this point and could undoubtedly do with some reinforcements, but the Dutchman has insisted he won’t fall into the trap of panic buying.

So, where does that leave the English giants with time running out in this window? Here’s what a dream outcome might look like…

Manchester United’s dream January transfer window: Clear some of the deadwood

Anthony Martial of Manchester United walks off after being substituted during the Premier League match between Manchester United and AFC Bournemouth at Old Trafford on December 09, 2023 in Manchester, England.

Anthony Martial has overstayed his welcome, somewhat (Image credit: Getty Images)

The rot at Old Trafford isn’t as deep as it once was but just a brief glance through the squad quickly reveals how far the standard has dropped.

There are players in every position who have had ample opportunities to prove themselves and have failed to do so, and when employees don’t meet expectations, it’s time to move them on. Ten Hag doesn’t come across like an overly sentimental person, so he must be desperate to clear the decks to an extent.

One such player whose time has surely run out is Anthony Martial. The Frenchman promised so much - especially after that derby goal on his debut against Liverpool - but has delivered so little.

The situation is complicated by the fact that he has just undergone surgery and is in the last year of his contract, meaning it’s likely he’ll leave United on a free in the summer, but in an ideal world a suitor would be found before the 11pm deadline on February 1.

Diogo Dalot is another who wouldn’t be missed. The 24-year-old isn’t the worst second-string full-back, but his positional play leaves a lot to be desired and has cost the team a raft of goals this term.

Bring in some creative flair

Antony of Manchester United looks on during the Premier League match between Manchester United and Aston Villa at Old Trafford on December 26, 2023 in Manchester, England.

United lack creativity – and Antony hasn't helped (Image credit: Getty Images)

It’s no secret that United have a serious goal-scoring problem. Only three teams in the Premier League have found the net less this season, so it’s little wonder they are languishing in eighth.

Rasmus Hojlund’s poor return – two goals in 16 league appearances – has understandably been one of the talking points, but the Dane hasn’t been helped by the lack of service.

In Marcus Rashford, Antony and Alejandro Garnacho, United have three wingers who, on their day, can cause problems, but that day arrives all too infrequently. They are also quite selfish players and often chase individual glory at the expense of the collective. That’s fine if you’re on the kind of form Rashford was on last season, but when the goals dry up, a problem is left.

To the naked eye, Rashford and Antony are particularly wasteful when in attacking positions. In 17 league appearances, Antony has contributed no goals or assists, while Rashford’s stats are only a little better. The glory days of David Beckham and Ryan Giggs are gone but more creativity from the wing is surely a priority.

United have been linked with Michael Olise, who is wasted at a struggling Crystal Palace. Even still, he has five goals and an assist to his name from nine appearances. Good with both feet, the 22-year-old would be a good addition and could become a regular starter on the right, with Garnacho on the left.

The defensive puzzle

Harry Maguire of Manchester United is substituted for Jonny Evans during the UEFA Champions League match between Manchester United and FC Bayern München at Old Trafford on December 12, 2023 in Manchester, England.

Maguire and Evans have started far too often for Ten Hag's liking this term (Image credit: Getty Images)

While problems exist all over the park, that United have been relying on Harry Maguire and Jonny Evans at the heart of defence perhaps typifies best where the club is right now. 

The return of Lisandro Martinez will surely end this nightmare but the lack of depth at the back needs to be addressed soon, especially with the ongoing concern over the form of Rafael Varane. 

During Alex Ferguson's reign, his sides were all built on a solid defence. The pairing of Rio Ferdinand and Nemanja Vidic was iconic, but the Scotsman also had the likes of Jaap Stam, Steve Bruce, Gary Pallister and David May to depend on during his 26-year tenure.

It's easier said than done and world-class centre-backs rarely fall into your lap, but if Ten Hag could lure the next coming of Paolo Maldini to Manchester, that would give them a seismic boost.

More Manchester United stories

Why Casemiro is backing Sir Jim Ratcliffe to bring glory back to Old Trafford

Erik ten Hag promises to 'deal with' Marcus Rashford after England star's night out

Andy Wright

Andy is a freelance sports journalist whose work has appeared across a number of print and online titles, including Golf Monthly, Eurosport and TNT Sports. He graduated in 2019 and began his career working in golf before joining Future in February 2021 as a staff writer for Golf Monthly. Andy has since decided to branch out into other sports and now covers football, rugby, snooker, UFC, Formula 1, boxing, and others. He is a Manchester United fan and joins the FourFourTwo team at an interesting time for his club and the game as a whole.