Premier League 2023/24 relegation battle the worst in history - as damning stats highlight clear issue

Luton Town boss Rob Edwards
Luton Town boss Rob Edwards (Image credit: Getty Images)

The ‘magic 40-point mark’ used to be a staple of the Premier League relegation battle lexicon. 

For years, the conventional wisdom was that once your side hit 40 points, your work was done there was no prospect of dropping out of the Premier League

But as the 2023/24 season reaches the home straight, the notion that 40 points are needed for survival is something of a myth, as laid out by the recent points totals for teams finishing in the 18th and final relegation spot. 

With just three games left this season, we could be set for a new low when it comes for the number of points needed for survival. Here’s a closer look. 

What are the lowest points totals for teams finishing 18th?

Gabriel Osho of Luton Town is turning away from Anthony Gordon of Newcastle United during the Premier League match between Newcastle United and Luton Town at St. James's Park in Newcastle, on February 3, 2024. (Photo by MI News/NurPhoto via Getty Images)

Luton are at risk of relegation (Image credit: Getty Images)

Here are the lowest totals for teams finishing 18th since the Premier League has had 20 clubs, which underlines the fact that needing 40 points to survive is something of a myth.

28 points - Fulham (2020/21)

30 points - Burnley (2009/10)

33 points - Wimbledon (1999/2000), Leicester City (2003/04), Crystal Palace (2004/05), Norwich City (2013/14), Swansea City (2017/18)

34 points - Manchester City (2000/01), Birmingham City (2005/06), Newcastle United (2008/09), Hull City (2016/17), Cardiff City (2018/19), Bournemouth (2019/20)

What about this season?

Chris WIlder manager of Sheffield United dejected during the Premier League match between Brentford FC and Sheffield United at Gtech Community Stadium on April 13, 2024 in Brentford, England. (Photo by SportImage/Getty Images)

Sheffield United are already relegated (Image credit: Getty Images)

With three games remaining and Sheffield United’s relegation confirmed it looks like a three-way battle for 17th place. Burnley are 19th on 24 points, Luton Town are 18th on 25, while Nottingham Forest sit outside the drop zone in 17th, on 26 points. 

Therefore, the maximum of points that a team finishing 18th this year can attain would be Luton on 34 points - and that would be one of the lowest totals for the final relegated team in the competition’s history. 

Should Luton win their remaining three to hit 34 points and still go down, they would join six other sides to get relegated in 18th place on 34 points. 

The Hatters still need to get some more points on the board if they are to avoid the ignominy of the lowest-ever 18th-placed Premier League points tally. 

Sheffield United are already down

Sheffield United are already down (Image credit: Getty Images)

That currently belongs to Fulham after they claimed just 28 points in their 2020/21 campaign. Next is Burnley on 30 points in 2009/10, while five other sides have finished 18th on 33 points. 

Therefore, the argument that this season’s bottom three are - points-wise at least - the worst in the competition’s history and that the bar for survival is the lowest it has ever been is still very much in play with three games remaining. 

This argument is underlined by the fact Everton have been able to ensure their safety with three games remaining, despite seeing eight points deducted, while Nottingham Forest are currently out of the drop zone following their four-point deduction. 

More Premier League stories

Manchester United star to leave in ‘sensational deal’, ahead of rebuild: report

Manchester City star could make stunning exit - with European giants reigniting interest: report

Liverpool make key transfer decision ahead of new manager's arrival: report

Joe Mewis

For more than a decade Joe Mewis has worked in football journalism as a reporter and editor, with stints at Mirror Football and LeedsLive among others. He is the author of four football history books that include times on Leeds United and the England national team.