Should Cristiano Ronaldo have joined Manchester City instead of United?

Cristiano City
(Image credit: Getty)

It seems a long time ago now, but back in late August Cristiano Ronaldo was widely expected to sign for Manchester City.

His agent Jorge Mendes had met with representatives from the Premier League champions and City looked in pole position to sign him from Juventus after they failed to land Harry Kane.

City midfielder Fernandinho has admitted there was a "considerable chance" that Ronaldo was going to move to the Etihad.

But according to reports, the striker suddenly began to have doubts about whether he would be guaranteed a starting role every week in Pep Guardiola's star-studded side.

City also reportedly became less interested in signing him when they learned they would be keeping Raheem Sterling, Riyad Mahrez and Bernardo Silva after speculation the trio could be leaving the club over the summer.

United were shocked to learn that one of their most iconic players could move to their hated neighbours and Alex Ferguson plus former team-mate Rio Ferdinand and compatriot Bruno Fernandes all intervened to make sure if Ronaldo was indeed heading for Manchester it would be the red half and not the blue half.

Ronaldo instead joined United, smashing a record for social media interactions and enjoying a dream debut as he scored twice against Newcastle to send his side to the top of the Premier League.

But as United prepare to make the short trip to the east of Manchester to face the leaders in today's derby, Ronaldo is on a terrible run of form, scoring only one goal in his last 10 appearances.

He will play no part in the derby after getting injured and was absent from the travelling squad.

But the fact that City are favourites to win the Premier League and Champions League and United are making a pig's ear of trying to finish in the top four, might well mean Ronaldo is seriously regretting the decision to go to Old Trafford rather than the Etihad.

And former Liverpool forward John Barnes thinks he would have fared far better at City due to the superior quality of Pep Guardiola's players.

"His goal record is great for a 37-year-old, but I think if he had come to City, he'd probably have 25 goals now, because the good players there would have found him a lot easier," Barnes told the Mirror.

"They would have had the vision and the technique to put him in, whereas I think some of the players at United simply don't have that vision to put him in on goal.

"Then there's the other argument that his legs have gone and he's not got the pace he had four of five years ago.

"I think what's probably got him frustrated is that he's not had the same service he's been used to in the past and people haven't seen him."

Richard Martin is an experienced football writer, editor and social media producer. Before returning to London, he spent 10 years in Spain as a football correspondent and has attended over 600 games across 16 countries, his favourite being Argentina. He has also worked for Reuters, The Telegraph, The Daily Mail, The Times and AS. 

Read more
Cristiano Ronaldo celebrates with the UEFA Nations League trophy after Portugal's win over the Netherlands in the final in June 2019.
'Cristiano Ronaldo is a man of football, I think he would have a massive impact if he joined Manchester United in some capacity when he decides to retire': CR7 tipped for shock Manchester United behind-the-scenes role
Cristiano Ronaldo celebrates with the Champions League trophy after Real Madrid's win over Atletico Madrid in the 2016 final in Milan.
Cristiano Ronaldo reveals sensational Barcelona transfer talks
Manchester City target Paul Pogba
Manchester City report: Paul Pogba drops hint over next move, after confirming Pep Guardiola talks
STOKE, ENGLAND - AUGUST 13: Kleberson and Cristiano Ronaldo pose for photographers on the pitch at Old Trafford on August 13, 2003 in Manchester, England. (Photo by John Peters/Manchester United via Getty Images)
‘Parma viewed him as the perfect replacement for Adrian Mutu, who’d left to sign for Chelsea. But Manchester United’s interest was much more concrete’: Cristiano Ronaldo's 2003 transfer details revealed by former Sporting director of football
Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola
Pep Guardiola’s transfer admission shows change is on the cards for Manchester City
Jack Grealish
Jack Grealish told to leave Manchester City - with record signing suffering under Pep Guardiola
Latest in
Fulham manager Marco Silva looks on from the dugout ahead of the FA Cup fourth round tie against Wigan Athletic at the Brick Community Stadium in Wigan, England on 8 February, 2025
'I think Marco Silva is the best manager in London - he managed to really maintain the desire to play attractive football, which was really hard over the years': Former Fulham talisman showers praise on 'impressive' Marco Silva
Manchester United head coach Ruben Amorim looks on following his side's defeat against AFC Bournemouth
Report reveals 10 Manchester United players leaving this summer
James Maddison of Tottenham Hotspur scores their 2nd goal during the Premier League match between Manchester City FC and Tottenham Hotspur FC at Etihad Stadium on November 23, 2024 in Manchester, England.
Tottenham and Manchester City could smash transfer record for British wonderkid: report
Tottenham Hotspur back row (L-R) Dele Alli, Mousa Dembele, Eric Dier, Davinson Sanchez, Hugo Lloris, Jan Vertonghen; front row (L-R) Son Heung-min, Christian Eriksen, Harry Kane, Kieran Trippier, Ben Davies during the Champions League match against Juventus at the Wembley Stadium on March 7, 2018 in London United Kingdom
Tottenham cult hero calls retirement - to avoid 'painkiller dependency'
Thomas Tuchel will take charge of England for the very first time this evening
'He pushed us. It was tough love, but that's Thomas' Former player reveals that the new England manager will be HARD on his players
Arsenal squad for 2024/25 LONDON, ENGLAND - AUGUST 11: William Saliba of Arsenal celebrates scoring his teams first goal with teammates during the Pre-Season Friendly match between Arsenal FC and Olympique Lyonnais at Emirates Stadium on August 11, 2024 in London, England. (Photo by David Price/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
Arsenal warned, as Real Madrid are coming for their star next: report
Latest in News
Fulham manager Marco Silva looks on from the dugout ahead of the FA Cup fourth round tie against Wigan Athletic at the Brick Community Stadium in Wigan, England on 8 February, 2025
'I think Marco Silva is the best manager in London - he managed to really maintain the desire to play attractive football, which was really hard over the years': Former Fulham talisman showers praise on 'impressive' Marco Silva
Manchester United head coach Ruben Amorim looks on following his side's defeat against AFC Bournemouth
Report reveals 10 Manchester United players leaving this summer
James Maddison of Tottenham Hotspur scores their 2nd goal during the Premier League match between Manchester City FC and Tottenham Hotspur FC at Etihad Stadium on November 23, 2024 in Manchester, England.
Tottenham and Manchester City could smash transfer record for British wonderkid: report
Tottenham Hotspur back row (L-R) Dele Alli, Mousa Dembele, Eric Dier, Davinson Sanchez, Hugo Lloris, Jan Vertonghen; front row (L-R) Son Heung-min, Christian Eriksen, Harry Kane, Kieran Trippier, Ben Davies during the Champions League match against Juventus at the Wembley Stadium on March 7, 2018 in London United Kingdom
Tottenham cult hero calls retirement - to avoid 'painkiller dependency'
Thomas Tuchel will take charge of England for the very first time this evening
'He pushed us. It was tough love, but that's Thomas' Former player reveals that the new England manager will be HARD on his players
Arsenal squad for 2024/25 LONDON, ENGLAND - AUGUST 11: William Saliba of Arsenal celebrates scoring his teams first goal with teammates during the Pre-Season Friendly match between Arsenal FC and Olympique Lyonnais at Emirates Stadium on August 11, 2024 in London, England. (Photo by David Price/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)
Arsenal warned, as Real Madrid are coming for their star next: report