Explained: The controversial Arsenal penalty that saw player punished for comments - and why VAR couldn't help

Lauren James of Chelsea is fouled by Kim Little of Arsenal, leading to Chelsea being awarded a penalty during the Barclays Women's Super League match between Chelsea FC and Arsenal at Stamford Bridge on January 26, 2025 in London, England.
Lauren James won the penalty for Chelsea (Image credit: Harriet Lander - Chelsea FC/Chelsea FC via Getty Images)

The Women's Super League London derby ended with a controversial decision which decided the outcome of the game.

The game had been a tight fixture but in the 84th minute referee Emily Heaslip gave Chelsea a penalty. Lauren James made a run into the box and Kim Little tackled her which saw James trip.

From the referee's angle she believed Little did not get any of the ball and awarded a penalty. Guro Reiten stepped up and scored to see the Blues do the double over their London rivals in the WSL this season.

London derby: Why isn't there VAR in the WSL?

Guro Reiten of Chelsea scores her team's first goal from the penalty spot during the Barclays Women's Super League match between Chelsea FC and Arsenal FC at Stamford Bridge on January 26, 2025 in London, England.

Guro Reiten in chasing the WSL Golden Boot this season (Image credit: Chris Lee - Chelsea FC/Chelsea FC via Getty Images)

Replays in slow motion seems to show Little getting the ball before she made contact with James.

Arsenal players protested but Heaslip stuck with her decision. The referee could not review the incident as VAR is not in use in the WSL.

Kim Little of Arsenal talks to teammates during the Barclays Women's Super League match between Chelsea FC and Arsenal FC at Stamford Bridge on January 26, 2025 in London, England.

Kim Little gave away the penalty that decided the game (Image credit: Alex Burstow/Arsenal FC via Getty Images)

The technology is not used in the English women's top-flight mainly because the large majority of home grounds cannot support the technology. Financial constraints are also a factor with a large portion of referees in the WSL not full-time.

Sticking with her decision, Heaslip copped some criticism from Arsenal's Katie McCabe.

McCabe was seen having words with the referee which resulted in her receiving a straight red card.

There has not been confirmation if McCabe will miss the next game but a player is usually suspended for the next fixture.

The penalty meant Chelsea won the game 1-0 to maintain their unbeaten run in the league this season. In FourFourTwo's view, the Blues will win the WSL title for a sixth season in a row this campaign.

The Blues are top of the table, seven points clear of second-place Manchester United.

The loss for Arsenal mean they are fourth and 10 points behind Chelsea. The defeat was also manager Renee Slegers' first loss since she took over from Jonas Eidevall in October.

Sarah Rendell
Women's football editor

Sarah joined the FourFourTwo team in September 2024 in a freelance role. She also writes for The Guardian, BBC and Rugby World where she specialises in women's football and rugby. Sarah has a bachelors degree in English and a master's in newspaper journalism.